Should I Form An S Corporation Or An LLC For My Small Business?
You have decided to delve into the business world and need to decide on a structure for your business. Or perhaps you are a sole proprietorship and wonder if you need more liability protection in the form of a business structure. This blog will explain the basic differences between limited liability companies, known as LLCs, and S corporations, known as S corps. Both are business structures offering limited liability protections and allowing pass-through taxation. Both entities create a distinctive legal separation between the business and the person who is the owner, which keeps the person’s personal assets, such as a car, house, or personal savings, protected from any liabilities or debts of the company.
An LLC is one of the simplest legal entity structures for a business. An LLC is a popular choice because it is easy to form, builds business credibility, offers more structure and protection than sole proprietorships, and is a pass-through entity meaning the company’s taxable income, debt, credits, deductions, and losses are passed directly to its members.
An LLC is formed when a document called Articles of Organization is filed with the California Secretary of State along with payment of a small fee. The paperwork and documentation required for an LLC is streamlined compared to an S corporation. A Statement of Information must be filed within 90 days after the Articles of Organization are filed and every other year thereafter. A Statement of Information requires information such as the address of the entity’s office, the name of the manager, the agent for service of process, the type of business, and whether any manager or member has an outstanding judgment for a violation of employment wage and hour laws. An LLC must pay an annual minimum $800 franchise tax to the California Franchise Tax Board to do business in California.
Although not a legal requirement, it is prudent to have an operating agreement for your LLC. An operating agreement is the document that lays out the relationship among the members of the LLC including their roles in the company, economic interests, voting rights, and restrictions on transferring their membership interests to other people.
An S corp is a corporation that has chosen a certain type of IRS tax classification that allows it to be a pass-through entity. Unlike a C corporation and, like an LLC, there is no double taxation, which is the term for separate corporate taxes paid by the corporation and taxes paid by the shareholders on dividends received.
The number of shareholders of an S corp is limited to no more than 100; all shareholders must be U.S. citizens; all shareholders must be natural persons, i.e., not other corporations or partnerships; and an S corp may have only one class of stock with no preferred stock options.
An S corp is formed when a document called Articles of Incorporation is filed with the California Secretary of State along with payment of a filing fee. A Statement of Information must be filed within 90 days after the Articles are filed and every year thereafter. An S corp must pay the minimum $800 franchise tax just like an LLC as stated above.
The company formalities are more extensive than those required for LLCs. Much like a C corp, an S corp must adhere to strict internal practices and formalities like having a board of directors, having corporate bylaws, and conducting shareholders’ meetings. It is wise to have a shareholder’s agreement to try to avoid disputes amongst the shareholders.
These are the basic issues related to LLCs and S corps. Each type of entity is subject to specific tax treatment which is not the subject of this blog. Please consult with your tax advisor on tax issues related to LLCs and S corporations.
~Rose M. Zoia is a director and shareholder at Anderson Zeigler. She has been practicing law for 37 years and focuses on business formation and transactions, real estate leases and transactions, land use, and appellate brief writing.



